About Us

Brighton-Pittsford Agency

Founded in 1953, the Brighton-Pittsford Agency has been providing comprehensive insurance advice to the Rochester community for over 60 years. As a full service independent agency we are not beholden to one insurance company. Instead – we work for our clients to provide the best combination of coverage and service available in today’s insurance marketplace.
We offer a wide range of competitive insurance products for individuals, families and businesses of all sizes. Our goal is to help identify your unique coverage needs and provide you with a range of options to choose from. Our partnerships with over 30 leading insurance carriers ensures that our clients consistently get the best value for their dollar. We welcome the chance to earn the right to be your trusted insurance advisors!

Meet the BPA Team

Lisa Dunn

PRESIDENT

Phone: 585.389.4153

Thomas P. Sapienza, CPCU

ACCOUNT EXECUTIVE

Phone: 585.389.4151

Robert T. Skuse

ACCOUNT EXECUTIVE

Phone: 585.643.2131

C. William Brown, CPCU

ACCOUNT EXECUTIVE

Phone: 585.389.1913

Wyatt Matulic-Keller

PRODUCER

Phone: 585.389.4157

Joshua Thurston

PRODUCER

Phone: 585.643.2130 Fluent in Spanish

Lisa Morrison

CHIEF FINANCIAL OFFICER

Phone:  585.389.4164

Judy A. DeJohn, ACSR

COMMERCIAL LINES ACCOUNT MANAGER

Phone: 585.389.4158

Heather Wolf, AAI

COMMERCIAL LINES ACCOUNT MANAGER

Phone:  585.389.4156

Jennifer Buczek

PERSONAL LINES ACCOUNT MANAGER

Phone:  585.643.2132

Robbyn M. Drew

PERSONAL LINES ACCOUNT MANAGER

Phone: 585.389.4155

Megan Dunn

PRODUCER

Phone: 585.389.4161

Nate Gardner

CLAIMS MANAGER/PERSONAL AND
COMMERCIAL ACCOUNT MANAGER

Phone:585.218.1210

David Scott

PERSONAL LINES
ACCOUNT MANAGER

Phone:585.389.4152

Peg Hobbs

OFFICE
ADMINISTRATOR

Phone:585.389.4159 Fluent in Spanish.